Not Good!

You may also like...

6 Responses

  1. barzilai says:

    You would think that והלכתי בדרכיו, what you call imitatio dei, would davka encourage לבדו.

    • micha says:

      And would one think that vehalakhta birdrakhav means we should kill people?

      I am still trying to make sense out of imitatio Dei. R’ Amital notes that the Sifri picks examples from the 13 Middos haRachamim. As in “ta’asu lefanai keseider zeh…” The problem is that the Rambam’s paraphrase in Hilkhos Dei’os does not. Not that I feel a particular need to follow the Rambam, but it does show that the topic isn’t open-and-shut.

      • barzilai says:

        I think pshat is that we have a mesora from Avrohom Ovinu that the true middos are rachamim, and we see cruelty only because physical vision is twisted and shifted.

        • micha says:

          Yes, that works on the hypothetical plane. But it doesn’t help on the pragmatic level — if we cannot see His Middos accurately enough to know how to emulate them, how can one fulfill “vehalakhta bidrakhav”.

          • Shlomo Engelson Argamon says:

            That’s why we get the 13 middot, perhaps – to tell us what to pay attention to, since we cannot figure it out just from our experience of Gd’s actions in the world?

          • micha says:

            See what I said in reply to “barzilai” — RYAmital said just that, but it doesn’t fit the Rambam Hil’ Dei’os 1:6:

            כך למדו בפירוש מצוה זו מה הוא נקרא חנון אף אתה היה חנון מה הוא נקרא רחום אף אתה היה רחום מה הוא נקרא קדוש אף אתה היה קדוש ועל דרך זו קראו הנביאים לאל בכל אותן הכנויין ארך אפים ורב חסד צדיק וישר תמים גבור וחזק וכיוצא בהן להודיע שהן דרכים טובים וישרים וחייב אדם להנהיג עצמו בהן ולהדמות אליו כפי כחו.

            The Rambam illustrates imitatio Dei with examples beyond the 13 middos, even adding “and the like” afterward.

Leave a Reply to micha Cancel reply

%d bloggers like this: